People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Whether we dine in, pick up or delivery the food is always consistently delicious. The owner and staff are wonderful and friendly. Great prices on food too. Our favorite take out in the area! They have the best chicken bacon ranch pizza and boneless wings! ”
“ I am from the Buffalo, NY area and I must say the service and food were phenomenal!! I am very picky about pizza and the dough and sauce did not disappoint. The staff was very welcoming and courteous. Would definitely recommend superb quality pizza!! ”
“ The owner lead pizza engineer is usually present at the store and is among the most hospitable folks in the pizza industry. Ask him about his pizza, youll hear the passion immediately! Eat the pizza, youll feel it too! ... ”
“ Food is excellent. Our regular orders include pizza, wings, tortellini, garlic knots and mozzarella sticks. Food is ready within 25 to 30 minutes. We have used both delivery and pickup. Very happy customers. ”
“ Absolutely the best pizza around. If youre craving good ol fashioned NYC style pizza, this is the place to be. Big slices and great taste for a fantastic price! The owner is super nice too, always offering ways to better your experience and constantly in a great mood. 65 stars, cant recommend enough ”
“ This is our favorite pizza place the best margarita pizza with sweet fresh sauce. I love that you can do two specialty pies split in one. Last night we ordered 12 cut margaritas and 12 loaded mashed and meat lovers Greek salad and a big ... ”
“ Best pizza around! My family eats here often after my sons work up an appetite at Jiu Jitsu next door. Crust is thin and crispy. Toppings are on point. The owner and staff are great! Highly recommend!!! ”
“ My wife and I are regular customer of Pizza My Love since they opened about 15 years ago. They have good prices and friendly service. My wife and I especially love the Veggie Lovers Pizza with a side order of garlic bread with cheese. The ... ”
Menu
Tiramisu
$8.99Raspberry Cheesecake
$7.99Strawberry Cheesecake
$7.99Chocolate Cheesecake
$7.99Assorted Macrons
$7.99
About
Pizza My Love
Welcome to Pizza My Love! Nestled in the vibrant Columbia Plaza of Rensselaer, NY, this delightful brand excels in delivering not just pizza but an experience laden with flavors and warmth. With a focus on quality, freshness, and customer satisfaction, Pizza My Love has quickly become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
At Pizza My Love, customers can indulge in a diverse menu that goes beyond traditional pizza offerings. From mouthwatering pizzas to enticing desserts and hearty salads, there is something for everyone. The crown jewel is the renowned Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, a crowd favorite praised for its balance of savory toppings and well-crafted dough.
- Diverse Menu: Enjoy a selection of pizzas, including classic styles to innovative toppings, complemented by a range of salads and desserts.
- Warm Atmosphere: Whether dining in, getting takeout, or opting for delivery, the warm and welcoming staff create an inviting ambiance tied to their passion for food.
- Catering to Needs: With options for outdoor seating, catering services, and amenities like Wi-Fi and on-site parking, Pizza My Love is perfect for groups of all sizes.
- Delicious Desserts: Don't miss out on the desserts! From rich cheesecakes to gluten-free options like the Flourless Chocolate Cake, these sweet treats are a must-try.
Many patrons have raved about their experiences here. Customer Emily Novak emphasizes consistency in deliciousness, praising both the food and the friendly staff. Amanda Williams, a self-described pizza connoisseur from Buffalo, commended the superb quality and welcoming service. Meanwhile, Tyler Burke describes the owner and lead pizza engineer as a passionate individual whose enthusiasm for pizza shines through every dish!
If you're searching for that quintessential NYC-style pizza, look no further. Customers like Andrew Krahforst-Lang claim Pizza My Love serves some of the best slices around, all at fantastic prices. You’ll leave satisfied—not just from a tasty meal but from the joy of being treated like family.
This love for pizza and community engagement makes Pizza My Love a standout. Experience friendly service, a cozy environment, and irresistibly delicious food by visiting Pizza My Love at 501 Columbia Tpke, Columbia Plaza, Rensselaer, NY 12144 or calling them at (518) 477-6666. Make it your go-to spot for any occasion—you won't be disappointed!
Book a table